Local

Cookies, donuts or pie? Here are the best bakeries in Youngstown Ohio, Yelp reviewers say

The Amish Market donuts.
The Amish Market donuts. Yelp

If you’re craving a sweet treat after a long day or if you’re planning a party and need a showstopping dessert, Youngstown has no shortage of delicious bakeries.

From pies, muffins, cakes, pastries and more, here are the best bakeries in Youngstown based on Yelp ratings and reviews.

Which bakeries in Youngstown are the best?

Here’s which bakeries Yelp users are raving about the most:

Classic Bakery

Address: 7135 Tiffany Blvd Youngstown, OH 44514

Yelp rating: 3.9 out of 5 stars

Yelp review: “Fantastic donuts, cakes, and pastries,” said Keith.

What to order: donuts, iced sugar cookies or birthday cake

Butter Maid Bakery

Address: 425 Boardman Canfield Rd Boardman, OH 44512

Yelp rating: 4.3 out of 5 stars

Yelp review: “Their products are spectacular in every way,” wrote Di B.

What to order: nutrolls, tarts, apricot cookies or clothespin cookies

The Bread Chef

Address: 850 E Western Reserve Rd Youngstown, OH 44514

Yelp rating: 4.9 out of 5 stars

Yelp review: “Totally incredible. Wow. Super nice from the second I walked in. Very helpful, very kind,” said Nick H.

What to order: fresh bread, danishes or scones

The Amish Market

The Amish Market donuts.
The Amish Market donuts. Yelp

Address: 6121 South Ave Youngstown, OH 44512

Yelp rating: 4.4 out of 5 stars

Yelp review: Absolute gem of a business,” wrote Nick C.

What to order: donuts, apple fritters or pie

Cerise Stone Mill Baking Company

Address: 3500 Canfield Rd Youngstown, OH 44511

Yelp rating: 5 stars

Yelp review: “Incredible, absolutely Incredible,” wrote Beth S.

What to order: scones, any pastry or tart

Have you been to any of these bakeries? Let me know in the comments or email me at cmadden@mcclatchy.com

Read Next
Chelsea Madden
The Telegraph
Chelsea is a service journalism reporter who began working for McClatchy in 2022. She was born and raised in Middle Georgia and lives in Forsyth. She attended Wesleyan College for undergrad and a few years after that, went to SCAD for an MFA in writing. Outside of work, Chelsea likes to watch Netflix, read books in the thriller genre and chase her toddler around.